1 year ago

E89 Episode 89: Hall of Fame Class of 1974

Hockey Hall of Fame Class of 1974: Bill Burch, Alt Coulter, Tommy Dunderdale, Dickie Moore

Bill Burch: 1922-33; 11 seasons, 5 quality by modern standard of PPG

Totals:
136G (10th All Time at his retirement)
60A for
196P (14th All Time at his retirement) in
390 Games (t-7th All Time at his retirement);
40.2 PS (18th All Time at his retirement);
At his retirement, Burch was 12th All Time in Offensive Point Shares
Among Forwards, Burch was t-17th All Time in Defensive Point Shares
Per Game: Burch doesn’t qualify for any per game leader-board, but if we lower the qualifiers to 100G, 50A and 150P, at his retirement Burch was
T-17th All Time in GPG
(last in APG among all qualifying players)
T-24th All Time in PPG
Era: Among the 10 skaters to play in at least 328 Games (4 modern seasons), between 1922 and 1933, Burch is
4th in Goals
T-4th in GPG
t-9th /last in Assists
10th/last in APG
5th in Points
7th in PPG
5th in Offensive Point Shares
8th in Defensive Point Shares
5th in Point Shares
82-game average: 29G, 12A for 41P
3-year peak (1922-25): 24-game average of 16G, 6A for 22P

Art Coulter: 1931-42; 11 seasons, 10 quality by DPS

Totals:
31G,
82A (21st/14th? D All Time at his retirement) for
113P (25th/18th? D All Time at his retirement) in
458 Games (17th/14th? D All Time at his retirement);
46.1 Point Shares (16th/14th D All Time at his retirement);
At his retirement, Coulter was as high as 6th All Time in Defensive Point Shares
Per Game: Obviously he doesn’t qualify, but if the qualifiers are lowered to the hilariously low 30G, 80A, 100P, Coulter is last in GPG and APG and 2nd last in PPG
Era: Of the 18 “D” to play in at least 328 Games (4 modern seasons) between 1931 and 1942, Coulter is
12th in Goals
T-13th in GPG (no Goals qualifier)
11th in Assists
11th in APG (no Assists qualifier)
11th in Points
11th in PPG (no Points qualifier)
11th in Offensive Point Shares
1st in Defensive Point Shares
6th in Point Shares
4th in Games
82-game average: 6G, 15A for 21P, 8.3 PS
3-year peak (1937-40): 48-game average of 4G, 10A for 13P, 5.4 PS

Tommy Dunderdale: NHA:

1910-11; 2 seasons, both quality
Totals:
27G for
27P in
21 Games
Per Game: if the qualifier is set to 20 Games, Dunderdale is
11th All Time in GPG
17th All Time in PPG
16-game average: 21G for 21P
Playoffs: no GP
Trades: Sent from the Shamrocks to the Bulldogs at 23
PCHA:
1911-23; 13 seasons, 11 quality?
Totals:
194G (1st All Time),
60A (t-5th All Time - Cyclone Taylor, Mickey MacKay, Eddie Oatman, Bernie Morris)
254P (2nd All Time - Taylor) in
231 Games (3rd All Time - Bobby Rowe, Smokey Harris)
Per Game: If the qualifier is set to 82 games, Dunderdale is
1st All Time in GPG
14th All Time in APG
8th All Time in PPG
24-game average: 20G, 6A for 26P
Didn’t bother to calculate a 3-year peak
Playoffs:
5G,
6A for
11P in
15 Games
Traded multiple times, I think
WCHL:
1923-24, 1 season, not quality
Total:
2G,
1A for
3P in
17 Games
30-game average: 4G, 2A for 5P

Dickie Moore: 1951-63, 1964-65, 1967-68; 14 seasons, 9 quality

Totals:
261G (11th All Time at his first retirement),
346A (14th All Time at his first retirement) for
607P (11th All Time at his first retirement),
+63* (9th All Time at his first retirement) in
719 Games;
65.2 Point Shares (13th Forward All Time at his first retirement);
At his retirement, Moore was 15th All Time in Offensive Point Shares
Per Game: At his first retirement, Moore was
16th All Time in GPG
T-9th All Time in APG
10th All Time in PPG
Era: Of the 36 skaters to play in at least 574 games (7 modern seasons) between 1951 and 1963, Moore is
5th in Goals
4th in GPG (8 qualifying players)
9th in Assists
5th in APG (10 qualifying players)
6th in Points
5th in PPG (8 qualifying players)
3rd in Plus/Minus
6th in Offensive Point Shares
18th in Defensive Point shares (5th Forward)
11th in Point Shares
82-game average: 30G, 39A for 69P, +7
3-year peak (1958-1961): 70-game average of 36G, 48A for 84P, +24*