Does Sergei Gonchar belong in the HOF? Did Phil Housley deserve to be induction? Our old-timer this week is Eddie Gerard

Does Kent Nilsson belong in the HOF with his gaudy PPG and short career? What about Makarov, who was never an NHL star? And what about Jack Walker, who didn't even have a great career?

Does Keith Tkachuk belong in the HOF? How great was Lindros? Was Harry Cameron the greatest D of his era?

Were the Sedins good enough to belong in the HOF? What about Dave Andreychuk? Should he have been inducted? Really? How good was Newsy Lalonde?

Does Turgeon belong in the HOF? Were they right to induct Kariya? How good was Cyclone Taylor? Was he really that fast?

Is Jagr the Greatest Right Wing of All Time? Does Mark Recchi really belong in the HOF? Who was Joe Hall?

Does Iginla belong in the HOF? Where does Selanne rank All Time? Who was Didier Pitre?

What do we do with amateur hockey players who never had the chance to play pro?